The joint between a cast-in-place wall and a cast-in-place roof slab contains a waterstop for a sub-grade structure. While installing roof beams, the waterstop became dislodged from the already-placed wall. A non-conformance report was issued. The engineer of record's repair detail showed to cut and remove the dislodged waterstop sections. The authority/agency re-approved the detail as the waterstop is part of a secondary waterproofing system and the primary system was deemed sufficient. The contractor did not comply with the detail and placed the concrete roof slab over the dislodged material .
In this scenario, which of the following options represents the BEST course of action?
A. Based on the engineer of record's recommendation, the contractor should develop a repair detail and submit for approval.
B. The concrete should be chopped out, rebar dowels should be drilled into the new slab, and the repair detail should be implemented.
C. The agency should accept as-is and rely on the primary system.
D. All slab concrete should be removed.
Explanation:
Per CMAA Standards of Practice (Chapter 5 C Quality Management and Chapter 6 C Contract Administration), when non-conforming work is discovered and the contractor fails to comply with approved corrective instructions, the appropriate procedure is for the contractor to submit a proposed corrective action or repair detail for review and approval by the engineer of record and the owner.
The SOP emphasizes:
“The contractor is responsible for proposing a corrective action for nonconforming work. The CM shall ensure the proposal is reviewed and approved by the design professional and owner prior to implementation.”
Accepting the condition as-is (Option C) would be improper without formal approval, and unilateral removal or demolition (Options B or D) should only occur after the approved corrective process is completed.
References (CMAA Construction Manager Documents / Study Guide):
CMAA Construction Management Standards of Practice, 2010 Edition, Chapter 5 C Quality Management, Section “Nonconforming Work and Corrective Action.”
CMAA CM Study Guide, Quality Management Domain, Objective 5.4: “Coordinate the review and approval of corrective actions for nonconforming work.”